Fauci’s “Noble Lie”: Denying That The COVID-Recovered and Already Immune Are Equally, If Not Better, Protected From Infection Than The Vaccinated.

The greatest deceit in the Biden Administration’s vaccine mandate is its irrational rigidity when in comes to millions of COVID-recovered and already immune Americans. This policy error, based in a terrible scientific lie, is creating a “silent majority” in our democracy against whom no president’s administration could survive.

Hooman Noorchashm
4 min readOct 16, 2021
In a chest beating and unpresidential address, President Biden Chastised Americans for not getting vaccinated.

Philosopher’s of old wrote of “The Noble Lie”.

The Noble Lie is one systematically told to the people by the elite/expert class, presumably to defend the whole of society against a “Moral Hazard” that would become material if the populace were to know the truth but misuse it.

But the philosophers of old also recognized that government based on The Noble Lie is doomed in one of two ways: 1) if the assumption that the people would misuse the truth were to be incorrect, and 2) when, not if, the people recognize The Lie and lose trust in the governing elite/experts.

In the year 2021, under the guidance of Dr. Anthony Fauci, the U.S. government is guilty of incorporating a “Noble Lie” into the Biden administration’s COVID-19 vaccine mandate.

Biden’s “Noble Lie”, is that the millions of COVID-recovered Americans with acquired natural immunity to SARS-CoV-2 are NOT equally or better immune to COVID-19 than the vaccinated — when, in fact, almost every reasonable immunologist and physician knows that the serologically positive, COVID-recovered are robustly protected from re-infection, perhaps even more so than the fully vaccinated.

But why this Nobel Lie by Biden — the president who was supposed to unite us and act with reason and transparency and “follow the science”?

The answer is simply that Dr. Fauci and the rest of Mr. Biden’s elite experts believe that admitting the facts about acquired natural immunity to SARS-CoV-2 poses a Moral Hazard to American society as whole.

But what exactly is the Moral Hazard of concern to Mr. Biden’s administration in telling the truth about acquired natural immunity?

The answer the elite give, in back rooms and private conversations, is that most Americans are “too stupid or paranoid” and will choose to get a natural infection as a pathway to immunity rather than get vaccinated.

Very literally Mr. Biden’s elite experts believe that by withholding the truth about acquired natural immunity, by stoking a Nobel Lie, they are saving America from itself — and Americans from themselves.

But in this assumption, Dr. Fauci and the rest of Mr. Biden’s elite are grievously wrong.

For starters, Most COVID-recovered Americans are in truth very well immune — serologically these Americans have a diverse and robust immune response to the whole of the SARS-CoV-2 virus, not just the static spike protein from the original wild-type virus. What’s more is that most of these COVID-recovered Americans, at the very least, already know that the need for an added vaccination is questionable.

In interview with Fox’s Shannon Bream, Penn Professor John Wherry is critiqued for lying to America, on CBS News, about acquired natural immunity to SARS-CoV-2.

But more importantly, when these already immune Americans confront the government with their doubts about the necessity of getting vaccinated when they are already immune, the Biden response is: “Get vaccinated, or lose your job, educational opportunity, and social connectivity — Basically, comply or stay home!”

In short, the irrational rigidity of the Biden COVID-19 vaccine mandate in the case of COVID-recovered is based in a Noble Lie, which Dr. Fauci and his experts have sold to the President of the United States, who is sheepishly imposing it on millions of Americans under coercion.

But Americans are a free people. We do not do well under threat of coercion — Mr. President.

My recent conversation with News Nation’s Joe Donlon on the Biden vaccine mandates and acquired natural immunity.

Of course, The Lie is being promoted and codified by highly decorated academic leaders across the U.S.: Fauci’s well decorated helpers — presumably well-intentioned scientists and physicians, who have bought into Fauci’s corrosive Moral Hazard argument. And who despite knowing better, based on their expertise and knowledge, act and talk with the goal of burying the Fauci hatchet…covering up The Lie.

An example of a well decorated accomplice to Fauci’s Noble Lie, one of many, is the leading Penn Immunologist, Professor John Wherry, whose florid recent lie to CBS News a few days ago is emblematic of America’s problem — listen to him falsify the facts about acquired natural immunity in the below CBS News interview at 7:15 on the video reel, below.

But, despite the falsifications and whitewashing being committed by the likes of John Wherry on the issue of acquired natural immunity, the clinical and epidemiological truth is that: the majority of COVID-recovered and serologically immune Americans are equally, if not better immune to SARS-CoV-2 than the “fully vaccinated”.

My colleagues and I recently published a review and meta-analysis of several large data sets from reputable sources and published it in the public domain.

You may read our analysis HERE.

Ultimately, the truth is that the Biden vaccine mandate contains a radical error in public health calculus. That is, it irrationally and unsafely forces hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of already immune Americans into unnecessary or very marginally beneficial vaccinations they do not wish to take.

The Biden vaccine mandate has buried within it a Noble Lie — but most affected Americans recognize this great deceit, and the consequence of recognizing a large scale lie emanating from the White House, and affecting millions of Americans, will only be damage to our republic. It harms people and it destabilizes our society.

I can only pray that rationality, real scientists and ethical doctors prevail in correcting the dangerous Biden vaccine mandate by convincing the president to relax the mandate on millions of already immune Americans soon.

Because the Noble Lie always ends badly in plural democracies..



Hooman Noorchashm

Hooman Noorchashm MD, PhD is a physician-scientist. He is an advocate for ethics, patient safety and women’s health. He and his 6 children live in Pennsylvania.